A fall alone does not make a property owner liable. In California you must show the owner or business created the hazard, knew about it, or would have found it with reasonable inspections, and failed to fix it or warn (Civil Code § 1714). For stores, the California Supreme Court has held that a jury can infer notice when a store failed to inspect within a reasonable period (Ortega v. Kmart Corp. (2001) 26 Cal.4th 1200). Sidewalk and public-property falls follow stricter rules, including a 'trivial defect' defense (Government Code § 830.2) and a six-month claim deadline (Government Code § 911.2).
At a glance
| Deadline to sue (private property) | 2 years (Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1) |
|---|---|
| Fall on public property | 6-month government claim (Government Code § 911.2) |
| Key issue | Notice: did they know, or should they have known, about the hazard? |
| Small sidewalk defects | Can be ruled 'trivial' (Government Code § 830.2) |
| Adjacent sidewalk duty | Owners must maintain fronting sidewalks (Streets & Highways Code § 5610) |
| Fee | Contingency: no fee and no costs unless we recover |
Slip and fall vs. trip and fall
| Slip and fall | Trip and fall | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical hazard | Liquid, produce, grease, ice, freshly mopped floors, worn or polished flooring | Raised sidewalk slabs, potholes, cords, wheel stops, rugs, broken stairs |
| Main question | How long was the substance there and did the store inspect? | How big and visible was the defect and was it reported before? |
| Key evidence | Video, sweep logs, employee testimony | Measurements, photos, repair and complaint history |
| Common defense | 'It was just spilled' | 'The defect was trivial' or 'open and obvious' |
Proving notice in store slip-and-fall cases
- If an employee caused the spill or mopped without a warning sign, the store created the hazard and notice is not an issue.
- If a customer caused it, you must show the store knew, or should have discovered it through reasonable inspections.
- In Ortega v. Kmart Corp. (2001) 26 Cal.4th 1200, the California Supreme Court held that a store's failure to inspect within a reasonable time can let a jury infer it had notice.
- That is why sweep logs, inspection schedules and video timestamps are the core evidence. Stores often keep video only for a short time unless asked to preserve it.
- Prior incidents in the same area (a leaking cooler, a produce aisle) help show a recurring hazard.
Sidewalk and public-property falls
- A city or county is liable only for a 'dangerous condition' that creates a substantial risk of injury (Government Code §§ 830, 835).
- A court can rule that a small height difference or crack is a 'trivial defect' as a matter of law (Government Code § 830.2). The size, lighting, location and whether anything hid the defect all matter.
- You must present a government claim within six months of the fall (Government Code § 911.2).
- California law requires owners of property fronting a street to maintain the sidewalk (Streets & Highways Code § 5610). Whether that owner is liable to an injured pedestrian depends on the facts and local ordinances, so we name both the city and the adjacent owner when the evidence supports it.
Evidence to save right after a fall
- Photos of the exact spot from several distances, with a coin, ruler or shoe for scale.
- Photos of what you were wearing on your feet.
- The incident report number and the name of the manager you spoke to.
- Names and numbers of anyone who saw the fall or the hazard before it.
- Your clothing and shoes, unwashed, in a bag.
- Measurements of a sidewalk or step defect before it is ground down or repaired.
Defenses you should expect
- 'Open and obvious': may reduce a recovery under comparative fault, but in California it usually does not bar the claim.
- 'You weren't watching where you were going': comparative fault reduces, but does not eliminate, recovery.
- 'We just inspected': tested against the actual logs and video.
- 'Trivial defect' on public property (Government Code § 830.2): answered with measurements and context, such as poor lighting or a crowded walkway.
- Pre-existing conditions: a negligent owner is responsible for making an existing condition worse.
Common fall injuries
- Hip, wrist and ankle fractures.
- Knee and shoulder tears that need surgery.
- Head injuries from striking the floor or a shelf.
- Back and neck injuries.
- Older adults often face long recoveries, so future care is a major part of the claim.
The statutes
Each law below links to the official text from the California Legislature (or the U.S. Code for federal law).
- Civil Code § 1714. Everyone must use ordinary care in managing their property and is responsible for injuries caused by failing to. Why it matters: This is the basis for a fall claim against a store or private owner.
- Government Code § 830. A dangerous condition of public property is one that creates a substantial, not trivial, risk of injury when used with due care. Why it matters: Public-property falls must meet this definition.
- Government Code § 830.2. A court may rule a condition is not dangerous if the risk was minor or trivial in view of the surrounding circumstances. Why it matters: Sidewalk cases are often decided on this defense.
- Government Code § 835. A public entity is liable for a dangerous condition of its property that caused a foreseeable injury, if an employee created it or the entity had notice. Why it matters: These elements must be proven in a city sidewalk case.
- Government Code § 911.2. Injury claims against public entities must be filed within six months. Why it matters: The first deadline in a sidewalk or public-building fall.
- Streets & Highways Code § 5610. Owners of lots fronting a public street must maintain the adjacent sidewalk so it does not endanger people. Why it matters: The adjacent owner may share responsibility for a sidewalk defect.
- Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1. Two years to file a personal injury lawsuit. Why it matters: The deadline for falls on private property.
- Civil Code § 3333. Damages compensate for all harm the negligence proximately caused. Why it matters: Future care for fractures and surgeries is part of the claim.
What to do now
- Report the fall to a manager and ask for the incident report number.
- Photograph the hazard with something for scale before it is cleaned or repaired.
- Keep your shoes and clothing as they were.
- Get witness names and note any cameras pointing at the area.
- See a doctor promptly, even if the pain seems manageable.
- Do not give a recorded statement to the store's insurer. If it was a public sidewalk, call us now because of the six-month claim deadline.
How we handle it
- We send a same-week preservation letter for video, sweep logs and incident reports.
- We build notice from the store's own inspection records, following the Ortega approach.
- For sidewalks, we measure and photograph the defect, pull repair and complaint records, and file the government claim on time.
- We identify every responsible party: store, landlord, maintenance contractor, city and adjacent owner.
- We document fractures, surgeries and future care with your treating doctors.
- Slip and fall cases are handled on contingency. No fee and no costs unless we recover for you.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sue a store for slipping on a spill?
Yes, if the store created the spill, knew about it, or would have found it with reasonable inspections and did not clean it up or warn (Civil Code § 1714). Inspection logs and video usually decide this.
What if I tripped on a city sidewalk?
You must show a dangerous condition under Government Code § 835 and file a government claim within six months (Government Code § 911.2). Small defects can be ruled trivial (Government Code § 830.2).
How long do I have to file a slip and fall lawsuit?
Two years against a private owner (Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1); six months for a government claim.
Does it matter that I was looking at my phone?
It can reduce your recovery under comparative fault, but it does not automatically bar your claim.
What evidence do I need?
Photos with scale, the incident report number, witnesses, your shoes, prompt medical records, and, most importantly, the store's video and inspection logs, which we demand right away.
Official sources
- California Civil Code § 1714
- California Government Code § 830.2
- California Streets & Highways Code § 5610
Talk to John
The consultation is free and confidential. Injury and employment cases are handled on contingency: no fee and no costs unless we recover for you. Se habla español. Call (951) 297-3707 or request a consultation online.
This page is general information about California law, not legal advice for your situation. Laws change; the statute links above go to the current official text.