A defective medical device can support a product liability claim against its manufacturer, but federal law shapes what you can sue for. For high-risk Class III devices approved through FDA premarket approval (PMA), most state-law claims that would impose requirements different from the FDA's are preempted (21 U.S.C. § 360k(a); Riegel v. Medtronic, Inc. (2008) 552 U.S. 312). Devices cleared through the shorter 510(k) process generally do not get that protection (Medtronic, Inc. v. Lohr (1996) 518 U.S. 470). Claims that the company violated FDA requirements can still go forward. The usual deadline is two years (Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1), and claims against the surgeon or hospital follow the shorter medical negligence deadline (Code of Civil Procedure § 340.5).
At a glance
| Deadline vs. manufacturer | 2 years (Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1); toxic exposure runs from discovery (Code of Civil Procedure § 340.8) |
|---|---|
| Deadline vs. surgeon or hospital | 1 year from discovery, 3 years max (Code of Civil Procedure § 340.5) |
| PMA (Class III) devices | Many state claims preempted unless based on violating FDA requirements (21 U.S.C. § 360k(a)) |
| 510(k)-cleared devices | Generally not preempted (Medtronic v. Lohr (1996) 518 U.S. 470) |
| Pain and suffering cap | Applies to claims against health care providers only (Civil Code § 3333.2) |
| Fee | Contingency: no fee and no costs unless we recover |
Why the FDA approval path matters
| Approval path | Typical devices | Effect on your claim |
|---|---|---|
| Premarket approval (PMA), Class III | Some heart devices, certain implants and life-sustaining devices | State claims that add to or differ from FDA requirements are preempted (21 U.S.C. § 360k(a); Riegel v. Medtronic (2008) 552 U.S. 312). 'Parallel' claims based on violating FDA requirements may proceed. |
| 510(k) clearance | Many hernia meshes, hip and knee components, surgical tools | Generally not preempted; ordinary design, manufacturing and warning claims can proceed (Medtronic v. Lohr (1996) 518 U.S. 470). |
| Exempt / Class I | Low-risk devices | Ordinary product liability rules generally apply. |
Common device claims
- Manufacturing defects: a device or batch that did not match the approved design, such as contamination, faulty welds or wrong materials. These often support 'parallel' claims even for PMA devices.
- Design defects: the device is unsafe as designed, for example implants that shed metal debris or mesh that erodes into tissue.
- Failure to warn: the company did not adequately warn surgeons about known risks.
- Failure to report: claims based on a manufacturer's failure to report adverse events to the FDA as federal law requires are treated differently in different courts.
- Surgeon or hospital negligence: improper implantation or follow-up is a medical negligence claim, not a product claim.
Recalls and FDA safety notices
- A recall or safety communication is strong evidence, but it is not required to bring a claim.
- Recalls are classified by risk. Class I recalls involve a reasonable chance of serious harm or death.
- Your operative report and hospital 'implant log' list the exact device, lot and serial number. We get these records early to see whether your device is affected.
- Do not assume a recall letter from the manufacturer protects your rights. It does not stop your deadline.
If the device is removed
- Explanted devices are critical evidence. Ask your surgeon and hospital in writing to preserve the device and not return it to the manufacturer.
- Manufacturers sometimes ask hospitals to send explanted devices back for 'analysis'. That should not happen without a protocol your lawyer agrees to.
- We send preservation letters to the hospital and manufacturer before revision surgery when possible.
Claims against doctors and hospitals
- If the surgeon chose the wrong device, implanted it improperly or missed signs of failure, that is professional negligence.
- The deadline is three years from injury or one year from discovery, whichever is first (Code of Civil Procedure § 340.5).
- Non-economic damages against health care providers are capped under MICRA, with the cap increasing every January 1 (Civil Code § 3333.2). Claims against manufacturers are not capped.
- We evaluate both the product claim and any medical negligence claim at the start.
Damages in device cases
- Revision surgery and future medical care.
- Lost income and earning capacity during repeated surgeries and recovery.
- Pain, suffering and loss of enjoyment of life.
- Punitive damages where a manufacturer concealed known risks, proven by clear and convincing evidence (Civil Code § 3294).
The statutes
Each law below links to the official text from the California Legislature (or the U.S. Code for federal law).
- 21 U.S.C. § 360k(a). States may not impose requirements on medical devices that are different from or in addition to federal requirements relating to safety or effectiveness. Why it matters: This preemption rule limits many claims involving PMA-approved devices.
- 21 U.S.C. § 360e. Sets up premarket approval (PMA) for Class III devices. Why it matters: Knowing whether a device went through PMA tells us which claims are available.
- Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1. Two years to file a personal injury lawsuit. Why it matters: The general deadline against device manufacturers.
- Code of Civil Procedure § 340.8. For injuries from exposure to toxic substances, the deadline can run from discovery of the injury, its cause and the wrongful act. Why it matters: Metal-toxicity and similar device injuries may be discovered late.
- Code of Civil Procedure § 340.5. Claims against health care providers for professional negligence must be filed within three years of injury or one year after discovery, whichever is first. Why it matters: Claims against the surgeon or hospital have a shorter deadline.
- Civil Code § 3333.2. Caps non-economic damages against health care providers for professional negligence; the cap increases every January 1. Why it matters: The cap does not apply to claims against device manufacturers.
- Civil Code § 3294. Punitive damages require clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud or malice. Why it matters: Concealing known device failures can support punitive damages.
What to do now
- Get your operative report and implant records showing the device name, lot and serial number.
- If the device will be removed, ask the surgeon and hospital in writing to preserve it.
- Check the FDA recall database for your device.
- Keep a log of symptoms, appointments, and time missed from work.
- Do not sign anything from the manufacturer, including 'reimbursement' programs, before talking to us.
- Call early. The deadline against a surgeon or hospital can be as short as one year from discovery.
How we handle it
- We identify the exact device and its FDA approval path, which decides which claims survive preemption.
- We preserve explanted devices under a proper testing protocol.
- We review recalls, FDA adverse event data and warning letters.
- We assess any medical negligence claim against the surgeon or hospital in parallel.
- We evaluate whether the case belongs in a coordinated proceeding.
- Device cases are handled on contingency. No fee and no costs unless we recover for you.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sue the maker of a defective implant?
Often, yes. If the device was cleared through 510(k), ordinary product claims are generally available (Medtronic v. Lohr). For PMA devices, claims are limited to those based on violating FDA requirements (21 U.S.C. § 360k(a); Riegel v. Medtronic).
Does a recall mean I have a case?
A recall is strong evidence but not required, and not every recalled device caused an injury. Your records show whether your device was affected.
How long do I have to file?
Generally two years against the manufacturer (Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1), possibly from discovery for toxic exposure (Code of Civil Procedure § 340.8). Against a surgeon or hospital, one year from discovery and three years maximum (Code of Civil Procedure § 340.5).
What should I do with a removed device?
Ask your surgeon and hospital in writing to preserve it, and do not allow it to be sent to the manufacturer without your lawyer's agreement.
Is there a cap on damages?
Not against manufacturers. Claims against doctors and hospitals have a cap on non-economic damages that increases each year (Civil Code § 3333.2).
Official sources
Talk to John
The consultation is free and confidential. Injury and employment cases are handled on contingency: no fee and no costs unless we recover for you. Se habla español. Call (951) 297-3707 or request a consultation online.
This page is general information about California law, not legal advice for your situation. Laws change; the statute links above go to the current official text.